Home 5 Articles and Reports 5 Royal Society of Literature: Ethical Challenges and Criticism

Royal Society of Literature: Ethical Challenges and Criticism

by | Feb 26, 2024 | Articles and Reports

 

the Royal Society of Literature which was founded 1820 is an institution that prides itself year in year out with nothing to disturb the peace of its members. But a letter in the Times Literary Supplement, by Jeremy Treglown and signed by 14 more distinguished writers (among them Ian McEwan, Alan Hollinghurst, Yasmin Alibhai-Brown and Fleur Adcock), calls on the leadership of the RSL to refer itself to the Charity Commission. That is, as charitable foundations go, something like demanding that they turn themselves in for questioning.

It’s only the latest fusillade in what seems to be something barely short of civil war in this longstanding institution. Many longstanding Fellows of the Society are deeply unhappy with the current management – principally its director, Molly Rosenberg and its chair, the poet Daljit Nagra. Everybody is briefing everybody, furious letters are circulating about leaks, and the whole thing is causing considerable distress to those directly involved.

 The Royal Society of Literature (RSL) has now confirmed that it is referring itself to the Charity Commission after the open letter.

The RSL, a charity which elects fellows based on literary merit, has been subject to criticism over recent months, including questions over changes to the way that fellows are elected, and the recent postponement of its annual magazine Review. Former editor Maggie Fergusson told the Times that the issue was pulled from print due to an article that was critical of Israel. It was also claimed that Fergusson was dismissed, although the RSL dispute this and say it had been previously understood that this would be her last issue of the magazine.

Fellows have also expressed their disappointment in the RSL for not taking a public stand in support of Salman Rushdie when he was stabbed in 2022. When RSL president Bernardine Evaristo wrote in this paper that the charity “cannot take sides in writers’ controversies and issues, but must remain impartial”, Rushdie responded on X: “Just wondering if the Royal Society of Literature is ‘impartial’ about attempted murder, @BernardineEvari? (Asking for a friend.)” 

Both Evaristo and the RSL tweeted in response, clarifying that the line in the article had not been in reference to Rushdie, and Evaristo pointed out that the charity put out two statements about the attack.

Additionally, the RSL has come under fire for expanding its fellowship too quickly. In 2018, a new scheme was launched creating 40 new fellows under 40. Since Evaristo became president in 2021, 60 extra fellows have been appointed as part of the RSL Open initiative, which aims to redress the charity’s historical imbalance and elect fellows from communities, backgrounds and experiences under-represented in UK literary culture.

To be awarded a fellowship, authors must have written at least two “works of outstanding literary merit”. While that remains the case, some authors have questioned whether the honour has the same prestige when granted to writers early in their careers. Former president Marina Warner told the Observer in January: “It is a question of a lack of respect for older members and a loss of institutional history, which was something fellows cherished.”

A representative from the RSL said the charity had decided to refer itself to the Charity Commission earlier this month “due to the sustained campaign of misinformation being made against us”.

“There has been no attempt at censorship”, the representative said. “The process by which new Fellows are elected has been in the public domain since changes were announced in the summer as part of the RSL’s 200 year celebrations.”

“The Review was not cancelled and Maggie Fergusson was not sacked [as she has claimed],” the representative added. “The magazine, which has no set date for publication, will come out in the spring and Maggie’s freelance tenure expired by mutual agreement.”

The representative went on to say that when the RSL team members and chair were shown proofs of the annual magazine at the start of December, it was considered not to be “good enough” for print. “We discussed with the outgoing editor a number of issues – stylistic, editorial and tonal – including querying the context of a written piece that referenced the war in Gaza. There was never any suggestion of editing the piece … The piece in question will be published – unedited – when the new-look magazine comes out in the spring.”

 

 

Recent News

15Jul
Tatsunoko Enters Publishing with TEEM BOOK

Tatsunoko Enters Publishing with TEEM BOOK

Tatsunoko Production, the legendary Japanese animation studio, has officially launched a new publishing imprint called TEEM BOOK, built on the pillars of universality, contemporaneity, and originality.   Founded in 1962, Tatsunoko is known worldwide for its iconic anime series such as Mach GoGoGo (Speed Racer), Science Ninja Team Gatchaman, and the Time Bokan series. With […]

15Jul
Leila Aboulela awarded PEN Pinter prize for her work on migration

Leila Aboulela awarded PEN Pinter prize for her work on migration

Leila Aboulela has won this year’s PEN Pinter prize for her writing on migration, faith and the lives of women. The prize is awarded to a writer who, in the words of the late British playwright Harold Pinter, casts an “unflinching, unswerving” gaze on the world, and shows a “fierce intellectual determination … to define […]

14Jul
Buenos Aires Publishers’ Fair in Focus

Buenos Aires Publishers’ Fair in Focus

Buenos Aires is gearing up to host the 2025 edition of the Publishers’ Fair (FED), bringing together over 330 publishing houses from Latin America and Spain. Set to run from August 7 to 10 at the C Complejo Art Media center.   Since its launch in 2013, the fair has grown into one of the […]

Related Posts

What Should We Read This Summer?

What Should We Read This Summer?

Nothing compares to a good book accompanying us through the long summer days, whether we’re sitting in the shade of a tree, stretched out by the sea, or stealing quiet moments at home away from life’s commotion. But the question readers often ask each year is: What...

From the Shadows to Leadership: Women in Publishing

From the Shadows to Leadership: Women in Publishing

For centuries, Brazilian literature was shaped by a male-dominated vision, reflected both in its narratives and its structures. Yet Brazilian women never stopped writing, even when pushed to the margins. Many wrote in the shadows, under pseudonyms or behind troubled...

Why Hesse Still Speaks to Us

Why Hesse Still Speaks to Us

On July 2, we mark the birth anniversary of the great German writer Hermann Hesse (1877–1962), one of the most influential literary voices of the 20th century and recipient of the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1946. Hesse was renowned for works that delve into the...

Previous Next
Close
Test Caption
Test Description goes like this