Home 5 Articles and Reports 5 US Authors Guild: Legendary Figures and Monopolies

US Authors Guild: Legendary Figures and Monopolies

by | Feb 4, 2021 | Articles and Reports, Blog

Whether those calling for a restructuring of the US book industry – and in particular, a long hard look at the power of Amazon – would go as far as to describe the current status quo as a paradise lost is not clear, but the Authors Guild has certainly cited the British poet and writer and author of that seminal work in its long, passionate letter to the Department of Justice, prompted by Bertelsmann’s move on Simon & Schuster

The letter says: “Perhaps no one has made the case better than the poet and political journalist John Milton, in Areopagitica, his foundational argument against concentration of power over the press, almost 400 years ago. He who ‘destroys a good book, destroys reason itself,’ Milton said.  Concentration of power over authors, he added, threatens to ‘bring a famine upon our minds’.”

Would anyone suggest that in publishing today there is a “famine upon our minds”?  There are dangers, yes – President Trump’s attempts to halt publication of books critical of him, the ‘no platform’ movements which arguably stifle debate – but these are separate from Amazon.  Some might argue that Amazon’s help for the self-published – its ease with which it gives them a platform – and its own Amazon Publishing imprints (AmazonCrossing, Montlake Romance, Thomas & Mercer, 47North, et al) are feeding the industry, rather than creating a famine.

But others argue, as the letter does, that “with decisions about what gets published and marketed widely (and so becomes discoverable) in the hands of so few, there is no doubt that many important books won’t get published, or even written.  Every time a publisher is acquired by another, we ensure there will be less diversity in the kinds of books read and the ideas exchanged.’  And so the debate goes back and forth.

The letter cites other historic figures besides Milton.  In words that some might describe as hyperbolic – and yet which are true – it notes: “With their ability to transmit and disseminate ideas and knowledge, books can have profound implications for the advancement of humankind, the exchange of ideas, civic discourse, and the maintenance of democracy.  For example, the Founders of the American Republic were significantly influenced by books authored by John Locke, Charles de Montesquieu, Jean Jacques-Rousseau, and Adam Smith. The Revolution itself was inspired to a large degree by the publication of Tom Paine’s Common Sense.  Recently, the Black Lives Matter movement was greatly influenced by a number of books addressing racism in the U.S.”

So a debate over whether a publishing group should buy another publisher is referencing the founders of the American Republic, a seventeenth century British poet and the very future of democracy itself.  Heady stuff.  Do any such protests work?  Well, the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) blocked one such takeover in 2000 when Barnes & Noble tried to purchase the book distributor Ingram.  At the time, the chairman of the FTC Robert Pitofsky said: “If somebody monopolizes the cosmetics fields, they’re going to take money out of consumers’ pockets, but the implications for democratic values are zero.  On the other hand, if they monopolize books, you’re talking about implications that go way beyond what the wholesale price of the books might be.”

The current debate is certainly compelling to follow, all the more so because of the wider questions it highlights about freedom of speech, democracy and access to knowledge.  It also shows – 250 years after the founding of America and 350 years after Milton walked the streets of London – the reverence with which books are held, and that of course, is to be celebrated.

Recent News

22Feb
YS Chi Wins 2024 Book Fair Lifetime Award

YS Chi Wins 2024 Book Fair Lifetime Award

YoungSuk “YS” Chi, Chairman of Elsevier and the Association of American Publishers, has been announced as the recipient of the 2024 Lifetime Achievement Award by the London Book Fair.   This prestigious award acknowledges individuals who have made a significant impact on the global book industry. It is open to professionals such as publishers, agents, […]

21Feb
Muscat Book Fair: Global Stories, Local Spotlight

Muscat Book Fair: Global Stories, Local Spotlight

The 28th installment of the Muscat International Book Fair commenced on February 21 at the Oman Convention and Exhibition Centre, featuring an extensive assortment of over 600,000 titles from 34 countries. This year’s focal point was on Palestine, exploring various facets of the crisis, while the overarching theme revolved around artificial intelligence, encompassing numerous events […]

21Feb
Booksellers Call for Gaza Ceasefire

Booksellers Call for Gaza Ceasefire

There were calls for the American Booksellers Association (ABA) to address the situation in Gaza at the organisation’s annual Winters’s Institute meeting, this year held in Cincinnati. At various sessions, booksellers voiced their frustration that the body has, so far, not backed calls for a ceasefire.  One member, identifying as “a Jewish person for Palestine,” […]

Related Posts

Bookstores’ role in today’s Enlightenment

Bookstores’ role in today’s Enlightenment

Bookstores, and in particular independent bookstores, play a role similar to that of coffee shops during the European Enlightenment – that is the interesting view of Connecticut English professor Rick Magee's writing in CT Insider.   He writes: ‘One of the driving...

China Room by Sunjeev Sahota – Book Review

China Room by Sunjeev Sahota – Book Review

China Room is a tale of injustice that narrates the story of an alienated youth who travels to remote rural India, where his great-grandmother lived in 1929, at 18, he is in the throes of heroin addiction. His account of a summer spent in rural Punjab is interspersed...

Books Published in January 2024

Books Published in January 2024

  Glorious Exploits by Ferdia Lennon The year is 412 BC, and Sicilian potters Lampo and Gelon are planning to put on a play – of Euripides’ Medea no less. Who better to cast in it than the thousands of Athenian men who lie about starving and practically boiling...

Previous Next
Close
Test Caption
Test Description goes like this

Pin It on Pinterest